Which One?

We're in the beginning stages of our landscaping

and have decided we'd like to have a garden shed

to store items like the snow blower, lawnmower

and all my gardening tools. The garage is big but

we want to keep it sparse ~ it houses two cars

and will soon be the home of a workshop for my

dh. So a shed is now on our list and worked into

our frugal budget. Now we have a big decision.

This first shed is from Costco. It is made from Resin

and appears to be sturdy. We like the look and it can

be painted if we choose to match it to the color of

the house. I'd put window boxes on. The only worry

is that Resin can in time wear down. And crack and

break. Will it hold the snow load in the Winter?

Our second choice is this one that a lovely family is

selling because they are moving. It's about $300 less

than the other one but we'd have to hire a company to

deliver. So price will be roughly the same for either.

It's made of solid wood and looks brand new when

we popped over to look. Their is a large door on the

side for getting large items in. We'd paint it to match

the house. The sturdiness for snow load in the cold

Winter months would be much better. And our sweet

landscape artist did suggest we find a "quaint"  shed.

What one is more appealing for a vintage look?

Which one would you choose if you have to decide?